(The Center Square) – An Illinois Republican lawmaker says high taxes, energy costs and regulations are making the state less competitive as two companies announce plans to eliminate a combined 316 jobs in Illinois while investing in other states.
State Sen. Chris Balkema, R-Channahon, who spent 31 years at Caterpillar, said the planned closures and relocations by Panduit and Ferrara Candy Company highlight Illinois’ failure to create a business climate that encourages employers to stay and expand.
Panduit plans to eliminate 162 jobs at its DeKalb distribution facility as it transitions distribution operations to a new facility in Merrillville, Indiana.
Ferrara plans to close its Little Village manufacturing plant in Chicago on April 27, affecting 154 employees.
The announcements come as both companies pursue significant investments outside Illinois.
Ferrara announced a $675 million investment in a new manufacturing facility in Orangeburg County, South Carolina. The project is expected to create 1,000 jobs over 10 years.
Panduit’s planned $76.5 million distribution facility in Merrillville is expected to create between 130 and 150 jobs.
Balkema said companies are evaluating their financial outlooks and finding better opportunities in states that offer more competitive business conditions.
“Yeah, this represents two more companies that are looking at their balance sheets, looking at their profits and losses and saying, hey, South Carolina, Indiana, so much better opportunities in these other places, and they’re making the decisions to relocate to the states that want businesses to grow,” Balkema said.
He criticized the Democrat-controlled General Assembly and Gov. JB Pritzker’s administration for not doing enough to attract and retain employers.
Balkema said Illinois has significant advantages when it comes to transportation infrastructure, including waterways, railways and highways, but argued that state policies are undermining those benefits.
“From a logistics perspective, we’re geographically in the gold mine,” he said.
He pointed to property taxes, energy costs and regulations as areas where Illinois could make changes to improve its business climate.
Balkema specifically criticized the state’s Climate and Equitable Jobs Act, which established a framework for transitioning Illinois’ energy sector toward cleaner energy sources.
He argued that lawmakers should reconsider provisions affecting natural gas and coal generation, saying energy costs could increase if the state cannot produce enough electricity to meet demand.
He also called for changes to the state’s property tax system.
Balkema said property taxes have increased faster than inflation and argued that local taxing bodies have too many opportunities to bring tax increase proposals before voters.
One change he suggested would be limiting property tax referendums to general elections, when voter turnout is typically higher.
The Tax Foundation’s 2026 Facts & Figures report ranked Illinois and New Jersey tied for the highest effective residential property tax rate in the country in 2024, at 1.88%. Indiana’s rate was 0.76%, while South Carolina’s was 0.49%.
Balkema said other states are more aggressive in offering incentives and predictable tax structures to businesses considering investments.
He argued that Illinois’ existing incentive packages are not always enough to overcome the state’s broader cost challenges.
“Unfortunately, it’s not enough for the company to see the long-term return on the investment,” Balkema said. “And so therefore, we end up putting a tax package in place. The company looks down the road and says, I’m sorry, we’re still not getting it done.”
Balkema said Republicans have introduced legislation addressing property taxes, energy costs, workers’ compensation laws and other regulations, but those proposals have struggled to advance in the Democrat-controlled General Assembly.
“We have bills filed. They don’t move, and that’s what we’ve got to change so that we don’t keep losing the businesses,” he said.
He added that Illinois should focus on retaining existing employers rather than concentrating primarily on attracting new companies.
Balkema said he is also working on property tax legislation that Republicans hope to introduce in the coming weeks.




